Topic: Spell Law II Errata?

[Marc R]

As we found more and more of these kinds of misconceptions we simply applied the same line of reasoning there.

Too much?

This would include Lists like:Earth ways, Magestaff, Air Mastery, Crystal Ways etc. All the lists listed here are from Spell law II I know.

Has any of you addressed this in some manner or are we the only group pondering as to what went wrong?

What are the issues with these lists, more specifically?

[Nders]

Oh they are the lists I referred to in the other thread concerning warriors element. They are all lists with the same progression in bolt attacks.

[Marc R]

So they all run into the same shock/water/fire/ice/lightning problem where ice and fire are not actually much of a step?

Any objections to pulling out the actual levels of spells involved? (at work, no books).

[Nders]

So they all run into the same shock/water/fire/ice/lightning problem where ice and fire are not actually much of a step?

This is the case yes

Any objections to pulling out the actual levels of spells involved?

Sure:

Earth ways (Essence base):       Bolt III level 11, bolt IV level 15, Bolt V level 20
Magestaff   (Essence base):       Bolt III level 12, bolt IV level 17, Bolt V level 20
Air Mastery (Mentalism base):   Bolt III level 11, bolt IV level 16, Bolt V level 20
Crystal Ways( Mentalism base): Bolt III level 14, bolt IV level 17, Bolt V level 19

[Nders]

Oh Lord of Lords, thou who wast formerly beknownst to all as the exalted Miller. Can we from thou well of wisdom a final ruling gather?

[Marc R]

The WE list is fixed with true offering 100' range, are the ranges on all these lists the same?

[Nders]

No some of them are 5'/level and others are 100'. But then again at level 20 where a good deal of the blot true/v spells are the range of 5/level equals to 100'

[Marc R]

Home again, perusing my copy.

[Nders]

Any progress my lord?

[Marc R]

I relinquished my title when I changed my name. . . .

Some similar change seems the best idea, just trying to work out if I need to give an answer specific to each spell, or if I can come up with a global wording for them all.

[Nders]

the problem with a global wording that does not use the words XX attack table for bolt true/V - for example flamer is that the spells have different ranges so a fixed range might be a problem. You could of cause make the range so high that it would be better than all of them. e.g. 200'