Kynac is a fantasy weapon with innate magical properties from Shadow World, much like the Irgaak.
The Armory provides balanced tables for real-world (well, mostly) weapons.
I've been playtesting them for years, none of my players prefer these to AL weapons for any reason related to power.
The Mullet and the Nodwick are, obviously, jokes, although there are situations where they may come in handy.
Now, this have been asked before, but the AL tables were taken from?
a)RMSS AL 1995?
b)RMFRP AL 1999?
c)RMFRP AL 2003?
The reason I ask is; any version preceding 2003 ed. is virtually the same.
2003 edition is streamlined with The Armory and both uses a slightly modified critical system; with this you choose the critical type rather than randomly generating it, before attacking. The attack is modified by attack type. For instance, Broadsword is a slashing weapon, but you can thrust with it, applying a -10 OB modifier. The armory tables are therefore missing the second letter in the entries (for instance, 21BS would be 21B). Also, the 2003ed version of the tables "skip over" two numbers per entry making them easier to read- for that reason, they are slightly less "granulated" then previous editions.
To be perfectly clear, this does not mean Minion needs any further customization in order to use the Armory tables (although it could certainly be done), but this makes the tables slightly less consistent with the tables in RMC because they don't offer randomized (or more precisely, varying) critical types.
Now, please tell me, have you received any of the attack tables from the Armory in json format, and if so, what tables? I might just sit down over the weekend and produce at last some of them. If you'd like, that is.